As I drove up to the largest IMAX theater in the world I saw
on the primary Marquee listings for the movies, Noah, God's not Dead, and Jesus
Son of God. Writing for Hollywood Jesus, Spirituality in Film, and The Virtual
Pew as I do, I am not ignorant of the influx of Christian themed films at present.
Neither am I oblivious to the controversies, both the real, perceived and imaginary.
The biggest story regarding movie releases on this day, is the release of
Noah.
Word has it, and there is good indication it is true, that the director of
Noah, Darren Aronofsky and the studios went back and forth with the studios
recently doing a final edit to appease the Christian audience of this classic tale
from the Bible. Aronofsky, according to some, isn't happy with the final
results and then there are the criticisms that have come about by some that the
character of Noah is too liberal, cares too much for the environment, is an
animal lover and the story as portrayed on screen is an environmentalist tale.
A notation here is the Biblical account in reality lasts only from Genesis 5:32-10:1.
With the movie lasting approximately 2 1/2 hours, there is clearly some
dramatic license.
It is likely Noah will offend many Christians, not so much
other Christians or religious groups, yet, at the same time, entertain those
wanting to see an action based movie. I suspect for example that what appears
to be the giant rock monsters, resembling the rock monster from the classic children's
movie The NeverEnding Story, in Noah (types of angels or protectors in Noah)
along with all of the action, many will think this story resembles more of The
Lord of the Rings than it does a Bible story. While those things didn't bother
me, (I love the parts of the Bible that actually does talk about Giants,
Angels, Demons, Monsters and the like) there are troubling aspects of the movie
not included in the Biblical narrative, that in my opinion wasn't needed and
took away from the moral themes.
Noah has a star studded cast with dramatic, albeit, sometimes a let down at times, special effects. The cast consists of Russell Crowe as Noah, Jennifer Connelly as Noah's wife Naameh, Ray Winstone as Tubal-cain, Anthony Hopkins as Methuselah, and others such as Ema Watson, Nick Nolte, and the list goes on. The cast is actually very good especially Connelly. The special effects as a whole are also quite good although there are lapses at times. I was disappointed in the sound in the movie, at times, blaring and overbearing the dialog. It was also interesting to look at early history humans with the ultra dirty hands but such pristine white teeth. The editing and story is also choppy and the final product on screen leaves far too many questions and the intent of what the story is trying to tell isn't clear at all. I don't blame the director Aronofsky, I have made comment before and will again, I want to see his version of the film.
Now all of this said, don't take my comments wrong, the movie is entertaining, but I left the movie confused and still find myself confused as to its intent. I also wonder will the movie do more harm than good in regards to getting people to understand this Bible story. While there are things I liked about the movie, unfortunately, some of those are things that apparently many attempted to have either taken out of the movie, or the themes of the movie redirected all together.
Noah in the outset is clearly an individual who cares for the animals of the
planet, and in fact, the planet. For those who have studied the Bible, this is
often referred to as The Genesis Mandate. There is a concept or belief among
many that God wants the people of this planet to care for the animals and
plants of the planet, not simply abuse them for their own pleasure. While they
are here for us, they are not here for us to abuse. I thought the movie in a
gentle way showed this side of Noah and did not feel that it was inappropriate
in anyway. The confusion comes about as Noah, primarily through dreams, and
what appears to be the usage of certain drugs goes into hallucinogenic states
or visions and hears from God, or what we suspect is hearing from God regarding
the destruction of the earth and the building of the Ark. We are never clear on this point but it
is clear, there is a God or Creator involved, we see miracles take place including
ultimately the floods. All through the process Noah is troubled, what is he
hearing from the Creator? What is the purpose of the flood? Those things are
never really made clear, although an attempt is made to give explanation as to
the objective of good and evil towards the end of the movie.
Another aspect I liked is the inclusion of the supernatural, including what is
hinted at in part, in the
There are components of the film that I did not like, I will be honest, I am
not so sure if I dislike them because of the way they were presented, or the
apparent conclusions that one can come to regarding the characters. Noah for
example is not a likeable character at all.
He will do all he can to save the planet but will leave an entrapped
woman fleeing for safety to be trampled to death. While many are shown to be evil
in society there are also the abused, especially women who are nothing more
than sex slaves, the poor who are abused, entrapped and imprisoned. Noah
struggles with the message he has heard from God, which seems to be inconsistent
with the Biblical account. He is even willing to sacrifice his own family,
while we have a scene that resembles in some way the story of Abraham and Isaac,
while the end result is the same, there seems to be no clear voice from God to
move him in the direction he moves. That all said, there are also worthy
questions to ask ourselves, how do any of us deal with the reality around us in
times of stress or in the places where hard decisions have to be made? Do we
listen to our own convictions and for those of us who pray, do we listen for
the direction and voice of God in giving that direction?
There is another component that many will have issue with,
that is a God who is willing to destroy the whole of the planet. Here I am not
as troubled though, I have no problem personally with a God who could create
the universe having standards, guidelines and expectations for that creation. It
is a simple concept really that many will take offense at, but I realized a
long time ago, I am not God! I have no
right, nor do I have the ability to dictate to God, the things that God would
choose to do. That said, my belief is also appreciative that God would provide
a provision to make it possible for all people on earth to experience the joy
and hope provided by God, to be in relationship with Him through the gift of
his son Jesus. Many will not see that as an answer, there are many theological
discussions that one could go through here but in its simplest form, the
conclusion of the story of Noah, from a Biblical narrative, is not the rainbow,
but it is the ultimate sacrifice, resurrection, and eternity provided for all
followers of Jesus through Jesus death on the cross.
I was anxiously awaiting this movie, truth is, I left the theater leaving disappointed
and confused. As mentioned earlier, I don't blame the director Aronofsky, I
haven't seen the movie he made, I saw a movie that seemed to be from the press,
chopped and edited to appease a select audience. While some are giving this
film the highest of praise, I just can't do that as I have a responsibility to
share my thoughts with those who read my reviews. I honestly don't know what to
think and was actually very disappointed. While an enjoyable movie to watch, it
is like watching an overly edited version of The Lord of the Rings, that is
highly intense, (far to intense for a young child, a friend with a young
daughter, around 10, had to leave the theater early on due to its intensity,)
and simply put, confusing as to what the plot objectives are for the movie. If
looking for an interesting take on the story of Noah, one is encouraged to read
the actual Biblical narrative and discuss the themes of a just, and yet,
jealous God or a discussion on how we hear from God there can be some positive
aspects to the film. My final conclusion though, many Christians, Jews, and
Muslims who follow and have as a part of their faith system Noah, will be disappointed.
Others, who enjoy good and entertaining fantasy will like this film, not that
Noah is fantasy but that is the way it comes across. It will be interesting to
hear the take of others on this, and I for one, anxiously look forward to
reading them. I will say, to save you
some money, I would have loved to have seen this movie in 3-D, that option isn't
available. Seeing it on the IMAX is available, that said, save yourself some
extra money, there is no redeeming value in my opinion of having to pay the
extra price to see it on the IMAX screen.
Over the years I have rated my films on a scale of 1 -
10. This one, I am just not sure about,
while parts I liked, there were parts I didn't like, some things were
entertaining, other things were disturbing. As a story though, as a film with
technical merits, I have to say on a scale of 1 - 10, for the feelings of
neutrality on this one, I give a rather disappointing 5.
To see the trailer for the movie Noah, just click on the following video, if the video doesn't appear, just click on the following link:
The Virtual Pew and our other work is supported solely by the kind contributions of others. You can click on the donate button below to give any amount to this work that does so much more than just post articles on the net; I draw no ongoing salary from the church I pastor, Mosaic Wichita which is predominantly a homeless church; I am grateful for any small amount you can contribute to help with this ministry. Believe me there is much more going on than most realize. I will also provide information to verify the ministry and income that comes into this ministry and work. Thanks and feel free to share any material from The Virtual Pew, I only ask that appropriate credit is given and a link to the original site with the materials provided.
Click here to read about, and order the book, The Keystone Kid
Click here to visit the web page The Virtual Pew
Click here to follow The Virtual Pew on Twitter
Mike Furches on Faceboook.
Click here to visit Mosaic Church where Mike is Pastor
The Keystone Kid/Virtual Pew Message Boards
Click to subscribe to my blog
There are hundreds of postings so make sure to check out the archives. You can also contact me for a free audio book link of The Keystone Kid at mike@furches.org You can visit http://www.thevirtualpew.com/.
Hopefully you will consider a gift to The Virtual Pew.
Now I get asked this quite often, Can we repost your blogs or articles? The short answer to that is, what an honor that you would ask, and by all means, spread the word. Here is our contact information
The Virtual Pew
1249 N. St. Francis
Wichita Kansas, 67214
Email: mike@furches.org
Click on the following links to learn more about The Virtual Pew
Donations to The Virtual Pew
The Virtual Pew Blog
Personal Furches Web Site
Hollywood Jesus
Reviews With Mike
The Virtual Pew Sermons
The Virtual Pew News
